Cookies on this website
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you click 'Continue' we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies and you won't see this message again. Click 'Find out more' for information on how to change your cookie settings.

Two thirds of people who experience auditory hallucinations will hear voices which criticise or threaten them. New research seeks to learn from people who hear nasty voices about what it’s like to be around other people. This new in-depth interview study offers a unique insight into the factors that lead to social isolation.

Illustrated picture of a person standing in the middle of clouds and a star shape. © Image produced by Scriberia

What is it like to be around people whilst also hearing voices?

Hearing voices can come in many forms. Some people hear voices that are friendly, helpful, insightful or inspiring.  Indeed, these kinds of voices can be very enriching experiences. However, others hear voices that are scary or critical. These can have very disruptive effects on day-to-day life. Whilst voices differ substantially, what unites all voice hearing experiences is that they are rarely talked about. 

The voices can seem incredibly real, and are often described as being very believable and difficult to ignore (Sheaves et al., 2020). Understandably they have a powerful impact on the individual.

One participant from the study explains:

“It’s a scary, scary, scary, scary situation, I’ve had more fear in the last two years than anywhere in my life.”

What factors lead to social isolation?

The study uncovered the following as factors that lead to social isolation for people who hear voices:

  • Difficulties during conversations, for example, concentrating on someone talking whilst also hearing voices is hard and tiring
  • Negative expectations of interactions, for example, fearing stigma and negative judgement
  • Difficulties sharing experiences of voices, for example, a selfless concern that talking about voices will leave others feeling upset 

Consequently, at a time in people’s lives when they most needed the support of loved ones, many voice hearers described efforts to manage the difficult experience on their own.  Being isolated wasn’t a long term solution, as another participant explains, “Not talking to people just made myself worse."

Several interviews revealed that social support was a crucial step in the process of recovery. 

 

“The more I could open up, the more I let my mates know, the more everything has settled down really.  

Is connecting with people important in helping people manage hearing nasty voices?

Speaking to people helped provide distraction from the abusive comments made by voices, it provided an opportunity to gather other information in an effort to question the nasty things the voices said and some actually described hearing nasty voices less often when they were around others.  The research suggests that connecting with people could well be an important vehicle in helping people to manage nasty voices, but this requires testing in future research.

 

Through my work in the NHS I have met many people who struggle with voices saying really nasty and abusive things to them. I am frequently left feeling inspired by people’s resourcefulness and strength for managing these really difficult experiences. Our hope is that this project inspires more conversations about voices, because nobody should be hearing nasty voices alone. - Lead author, Dr Bryony Sheaves, Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford.

  

To read the full paper, The challenges and opportunities of social connection when hearing derogatory and threatening voices: A thematic analysis with patients experiencing psychosis

To read an article in The Conversation, Hearing voices can be frightening and isolating - but talking can help.

Watch an inspiring animation, produced in collaboration with the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Oxford and the McPin Hearing Voices Lived Experience Advisory Panel. The animation shares the stories of people who hear one type of voices: those which threaten them or criticise them.

 

   

 

NIHR OXFORD HEALTH BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH CENTRE NEWS

Please follow the link below to read the news on the NIHR BRC website.

Similar stories

New Way of Understanding Dissociation Could Improve Patient Care

Mental Health Psychosis

New research has developed a novel measure of dissociative experiences that share a subjective 'felt sense of anomaly'. This new approach could revolutionise how clinicians understand dissociative experiences across a range of mental health disorders, and how they work with patients with dissociation in the future.

Covid-19 vaccination programme: where do people with mental health difficulties lie within the order of priority?

COVID-19 Mental Health

A new blog authored by mental health clinicians and researchers in the Department of Psychiatry and Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust, and published in thebmjopinion, discusses the priority groups for COVID-19 vaccinations.

New Analysis Challenges Guidelines on Treating Anorexia Nervosa

Mental Health Psychological therapy

A new analysis, published in The Lancet Psychiatry, has shown a lack of strong evidence to support current guidance on psychological therapies for treating anorexia nervosa over expert treatment as usual.

Children’s Mental Health Worse in the New Lockdown

Anxiety COVID-19 Child and adolescent Early intervention Mental Health Psychological therapy

The proportion of secondary school aged girls with emotional problems in January 2021 was at the highest level reported since March 2020, highlights latest report from the Co-SPACE study. It also shows parent and carer reported behavioural, emotional, and restless/attentional difficulties in their offspring have increased again since the latest national lockdown was introduced.

New WA Handley Chair of Psychiatry Appointed

Awards Mental Health

Professor John Geddes has been appointed to the WA Handley Professorship of Psychiatry and will take up this post in November 2021. He will be a fellow of Merton College. A donation from the WA Handley Trust endowed the first Chair of Psychiatry in the University of Oxford’s Department of Psychiatry, which was founded in 1969.

Improving Experiences of People with Serious Mental Health Problems

Mental Health

A project led by Professor Kam Bhui and Dr Roisin Mooney, University of Oxford, will focus on reducing the number of people admitted or readmitted to compulsory care under the Mental Health Act. This is one of four new research projects funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) with the aim to improve patient experiences and outcomes under the Mental Health Act.